Digression:
This uncertainty about dates does not improve;
in fact it gets worse. Because we know the date
of Archimedes' death and can deduce
something about the logical connections between
his work and Euclid's, we are reasonably certain
to within a few dozen years about when Euclid lived.
But for the later mathematician Diophantus
the period of uncertainty is much more extensive.
Estiamtes range up to a span of 500 years!
The problem is discussed in an
interesting article on Diophantos by Norbert Schappacher.
This is quoted
by the Wikipedia article on Diophantus,
but Schappacher's message is ignored.
People believe what they want to believe.
It is often asserted that Archimedes was born in
287 B. C., but (as mentioned timidly in one of the
Wikipedia articles)
this is based on an assertion made
without further explanation in Byzantium
1400 years after his death that he
was 75 years old when he died.
|